“The strong bond of friendship is not always a balanced equation; friendship is not always about giving and taking in equal shares. Instead, friendship is grounded in a feeling that you know exactly who will be there for you when you need something, no matter what or when.”
Simon Sinek
This weekend, I spent time with one of my friends. I’ve known her since 2004 and she is wise, beautiful inside and out and always, always there for me (except on one occasion when she was meant to be nursing me and instead I ended up nursing her after a few too many Zambucas, then – after she passed out – left to my own devices, I somehow ended up giving a lap dance in four inches of mud to a male friend of mine and then kissing a random stranger…but that’s another story).
Anyway, after we had had a couple of drinks, gone for some food and then spent the evening in the company of Robbie Williams and a few thousand other people, we got back to the hotel and crashed out with a room service pizza. We chatted and I confided in her about another friend of mine and how I thought that the ten year relationship that I had been in with this other friend was over.
I have read a few articles on the interweb about the phenomena that is ‘ghosting’ – when one person in a relationship suddenly stops all communication with the other. And this is kind of where my relationship with my other friend had got to but rather than being sudden – this had happened over the last 18 months.
The reasons for this I am still trying to understand .
We met back in 2006, when we became neighbours. She moved in two doors down from me and we chatted and gradually got closer. We are similar in age, we were both single then and we both had similar outlooks on life. She was intelligent, hard working and kind. We socialised – including her popping round for coffee, chats and cigarettes most nights and over time we built a friendship based on mutual respect and fun. We got close- confiding in each other and sharing fears, secrets, hopes and dreams.
We socialised – I introduced her to a group of my friends and we all went camping and had some nights out together. We also planned to go to Glastonbury together – which we did eventually and had great fun – although we nearly both melted in the heat.
When she met her now husband in 2007 and then got engaged in 2008 – I could not have been happier for her. She asked me to be one of her bridesmaids – along with her sister in law – I felt honoured and excitedly agreed.
Life took a bit of a turn for me in 2009. Another really good friend of mine (who she also knew) died suddenly. Like the loyal, empathic friend that she was, she was there for me every step of the way from the shocking news of his death to the funeral and beyond. I couldn’t have got through it without her.
It was her that eventually persuaded me that I needed to take some time out from work to recover a bit – as mentally I wasn’t coping. Again- she was there as a constant source of support.
At about the same time my ex partner and father of my daughter decided to take me to court (the details of which are so boring and not worth writing about) and my friend was there for me again. She took the day off work and came with me to the court room to hold my hand. Again, I could not have got through it without her.
Another time, I remember was when I hurt my back so badly that I could not stand up for a few days. Again, my friend was there for me. She quite often worked from home and so she was on call to help me when I needed her.
On the odd occasion she would look after my daughter – whom she seemed to be very fond of – and her cousin also became a regular babysitter for me.
My daughter was having problems at school at the time – and again- my friend was supportive, wise and kind. Again, I couldn’t have got through it without her.
So -as you can see- she was a wonderful, supportive and loving friend.
When her wedding day was approaching, I arranged her Hen weekend and was really proud to walk behind her down the aisle. It was a lovely day, one that she truly deserved. Very well organised and planned and executed. I was so proud of her and she looked so beautiful in the dress that I had helped her choose. Through this process, I also got to know her family a bit better – one of her sisters in law and her parents. I got on well with them – they seemed nice. We had a few meals together over this time period. I also really fancied one of her brothers- whom I had met on a number of occasions. He was married with three children – so clearly a ‘no go’.
After she got married at the end of 2009, she immediately wanted to try for a family. This proved difficult. She miscarried a few times. She became very focussed on getting pregnant and I like to think I was there for her. I tried to get her to relax a bit about it, knowing that she had, for many years, suffered with anxiety and seeing that the sadness and pain of finding it hard to conceive was taking a mental toll. Eventually, she did fall pregnant and this time, thankfully- she didn’t miscarry. Someway into her pregnancy, her husband and her decided to move house- closer to her family – but still only 20 minutes or so away from me. They sold the house, packed up and moved.
The day after she moved, I was there, along with her parents- cleaning the house (as she was heavily pregnant by this time) and taking time off work to help her when I could.
The day came when she gave birth to a beautiful baby girl. She had a difficult time in labour and some complications, but as soon as I heard that she was well enough for visitors- I was there- at the hospital to comfort, support and share in her joy.
Her husband was away in the army – so as she was a new mum- I tried to help where I could – even if it was just popping ’round to try and give her an hand and a bit of a break when I could. Her daughter was (and still is) adorable. She had a very definite idea of how she wanted to parent her daughter – one which her family quite often didn’t agree with. We talked a lot about this. I understood what she wanted to do regarding parenting and I whole heartedly supported her.
From there- my daughter and I were kind of treated like family. Family BBQs at her house- we were always invited, her daughter’s christening – we were invited. That sort of thing. Close family friends.
When her brother got divorced in 2011, he stayed at her house for a while. I was sad to hear of the end of his 10 year marriage and the circumstances around it. His now ex-wife was ‘painted’ very badly by the whole of my friend’s family. I remember thinking that were two sides to every story and that affairs don’t happen for no reason. When I saw her brother at my friends’ house- he looked broken, but was also very swiftly putting plans in place regarding finances and their children. I remember having a jokey conversation with my friend about how it was a shame that I was in a relationship as I would have like to ‘help to distract’ her brother from his pain. I still fancied him. Apparently- he too had a similar conversation with her.
Within a week though – he was in a new relationship. I met his girlfriend on a number of occasions. She seemed nice, young and totally unsuited to him. Still, he moved her in with him and so there they were – him newly divorced – getting on with a new relationship. I remember thinking at the time that it was all very quick.
Early in 2013, I received a text from my friend that her brother had broken up from his new girlfriend and was single and would like my phone number. I too was single and so I happily and excitedly told her to pass on my number.
From there – we texted a few times and arranged a date. The morning after our date- I called my friend and told her all the details. We carried on dating and got more serious and after six months of falling in love, he asked if my daughter and I would like to move in with him – which we did a few months later.
I’m not going to rehash my relationship with my friend’s brother in this post. This post is not really about him. But suffice to say that being with him felt like the final piece of the jigsaw. I was madly in love with him and him with me- and the family that I had got to know through being friends with his sister for seven years became my family and his sister became more than my friend – she became my sister.
As we now only lived five minutes away – we saw a lot of each other. I baby sat on a few occasions. We had family weekends away together. I hosted Christmas for the whole family – the first one that they had ever had all together. My now sister would pop round with her (now two) daughters for lunch/tea/chats and coffee. On the very odd occasion she had some time away from her daughters – we went out. I naturally became closer to her parents and her sister in law and her other brother. I confided in them. They confided in me. We were all close.
My daughter was going through a hard time during this period – suffering from what we now know was depression and anxiety. My friend’s family were very supportive and understanding to us all. I cherished and valued them.
My friend’s marriage went through bit of a blip after her second child was born. Being the type of family where the difficult things never really got talked about – she turned to me for support – when her parents didn’t really seem to have any insight. I tried to talk and listen to both her and her husband and tried in my way to help them the best I could. I loved them and cared about them both and it hurt to see them struggling. They got through it though. Her husband was also suffering from depression due to various life changes – and I also tried to listen and counsel him. That’s what family does, right? You help where you can when your loved ones are having problems. You take a step back, see the bigger picture, you listen and you try to empower them to make it work.
So – as you can see – we were family – my friend and I. I was now officially ‘Aunty Kate’ to her daughters . I was step mum to her nieces and nephew. She was now officially ‘Aunty’ to my daughter. We talked about a possible future wedding – that her brother had hinted at on several occasions and got excited. My partner and I were also having a massive amount of house renovations at the time and she helped me with the planning and was supportive through what was proving to be a very stressful experience.
And now we get to the bit that I am still processing, still working through, still trying to understand.
You see – in November 2015, the relationship that I thought was going to last forever – ended. Again I am not going to rehash this in great detail in this post. I have been over and over it in my head, in therapy sessions, with friends and with family and still – nearly two years on- I can not make any real sense of it.
It happened very suddenly. Looking back – we had been having a few issues for a while – although knowing what I know now- these were issues that many ‘blended’ families have around boundaries and adjustment- made more difficult with the undiagnosed anxiety and depression that my daughter was suffering from, my partner’s ex wife having a new baby, a massive amount of house renovations and my partner’s inability to put in boundaries with his children or to discuss anything ‘difficult’. That family trait of brushing things under the carpet was very present.
So, yes. It ended. I left as I could not live in a house where my daughter was no longer welcome. Without her there – it could no longer be my home and my partner had decided that she was a ‘danger’ to his children (in fact I think the word he used to describe her to his mother was ‘satan’) and that she could no longer live there. Anyone who knows my daughter – knows how utterly ridiculous this is.
In the two weeks between him chucking her out of the house and me leaving – I tried to talk to him about it, but he was resolute. I had no choice. I had to leave. It broke me. Properly broke me. I had had relationships before. These had ended. This, though was very different. I’m tough, strong, resilient – I know this to be true of myself and I hung on to this knowledge for dear life because for the first time in my life I now felt as though I wouldn’t ever recover. For the first time in my life, I was properly broken.
Despite every bone in my body telling me to stay – I had to leave. I had to leave behind the children that I had grown to love as my own . I knew the damage this would do to them and this tore me up inside- and yet I had no choice. The home that we had lovingly designed and built and that was near to being completed – I walked away from. Most of all – the man that I thought was my soul mate, my lover and my best friend – I had to leave. It broke me.
And it broke my daughter. The man she had come to regard as her father had rejected her. She tried to persuade me to stay – but how could I? I could not abandon my daughter. She had been through enough in her 17 years. She felt like it was all her fault. It wasn’t of course. It was no-one’s fault. It was two adults trying to cope with difficult step family dynamics. One of them gave up and so the other one had to go. They failed. They failed each other. They failed their children – their family. They needed help.
And yet that help didn’t come. In fact- I discovered that rather than helping us to repair our relationship, his family had been having discussions behind my back about us and what he should do to minimise the damage that the end of the relationship would have. This hurt. This hurt especially as I had turned to my partner’s mother for support and she promised that she would help us, that she would talk to my partner, that she believed that it was a blip and we would get over it as we were ‘so perfect’ for each other.
But it wasn’t a blip. And so I walked away when it got to the point where it seemed like it was irreparable, when my partner said that he wouldn’t go to couples counselling, that he was done trying. I walked away when I realised that the man I loved was incapable of taking any responsibility for what had gone wrong and when I realised that the family that I had grown to regard as my own had now taken sides. I walked away and it broke me.
Now- I was no longer the woman that my partner’s mother had said had healed her son and allowed him to be himself and that had made him so ecstatically happy. Now I was no longer the step mother who was ‘brilliant’ with the children, who cooked for them, washed they clothes, tidied their rooms, took them out, looked after them, did their homework with them, talked to them when they had problems, tried to maintain some normality when the house was covered in brick dust and loved them. Now I was no longer the bridesmaid, the counsellor, the family friend of ten years. Now- I was just some inconvenience to be got rid of – someone that my partner told his mother via text he would replace ‘ with another girlfriend who doesn’t have a psychotic daughter’. Ironic – coming from a man whose sister, sister in law and mother have all been dependent on mental health medication for many years. I mistakenly thought he understood my daughter.
Now homeless – and living back with my parents – jobless and without a penny in the bank – I had lost everything. I still had my own house- rented out at the time – but I had no way of paying for it- so couldn’t go back there. It was a very dark time. . The loss was huge and so painful. All those hopes, dreams and plans that we had made for the future – gone. All that love, joy and laughter. Gone. Looking back- I am not sure how I got through it. I know that my own family and my dear friends were a massive support through it all.
The one thing I thought would survive – was my relationship with my friend. We had been friends for many years before – and so I thought that we would – after the dust had settled – remain friends. I knew this would be difficult. I knew our relationship would change. But I thought we would survive this.
In the early days after I left – we met up for coffee and talked. Things had become very difficult with the separation at this point – concerning finances. I was forced to take some action that I did not really want to do in order to claim back what was mine.
I remember thinking as we sat and drank our coffee – that as my friend had known me for so long, she knew my values, my morals and my heart. I remember thinking that she would understand that I had to take the action that I did. I remember thinking that she knew that I would never do anything out of spite and bitterness and that now I was in ‘survival’ mode- I was doing what I had to do to survive. I discussed all of this with her and it seemed like she understood.
This was a very confusing and painful time. I knew she couldn’t say much. My ex is her brother after all. Blood. I knew she couldn’t hold my hand through this, like she had done so many times before and I knew that the action I was taking was causing a strain to her family. But I thought she would understand.
I thought perhaps she might even say to her brother and the rest of her family “Hold on- this is Kate we are talking about. The woman I have known intimately for ten years – not some random that was picked up in a bar. This is the woman who does not have a mean bone in her body, who walked behind me down the aisle, who comforted me when I needed it – who comforted us all when we needed it – who would never intentionally hurt anyone – but if she has to – she will fight. Be kind to her. Be fair. Give her back what is rightfully hers. Don’ t make her fight when she has lost everything and is hurting so deeply”. I guess I hoped that out of the wreckage – out of the way that I guessed I was now being portrayed, I hoped that she would still know me. Would still believe in me.
When my ex partner and I started ‘seeing’ each other again – some two months after we split up – I confided in my friend. I was still at this point – wanting so much to be back in the relationship – as did my ex. For a while it seemed like there was some hope and so I spoke about it briefly with her.
But the reconciliation never happened. There was, I guess, too much damage to repair. The financial affairs were sorted eventually and I began to move on with my life. To put myself back together bit by bit. A long and slow process with one step at a time.
I saw my friend again shortly after I stopped seeing my ex. She popped round to my house that I had since moved back in to. We chatted and she told me that my ex had moved on to someone new.
I thought about this for a while….quite a while. And I thought about all of the things he had said while we were trying to repair our relationship. His patterns of fixing the pain, brushing it under the carpet and moving on – were still in place – whereas I have had to work hard at learning from the past and altering my habitual patterns of relating. The definition of an idiot after all- it is said – is someone who does the same thing over and over and expects different results. I’m not an idiot. Naive maybe. Too trusting maybe. But not an idiot.
And so now – it’s 18 months since the split and nine months since I last saw my friend.
The ‘ghosting’ gradually started a few months ago.
At first it was not replying to my messages – or taking ages to reply – always with some excuse. Still- I kept on messaging. Not about her brother or anything like that- just messages enquiring about how she was or how her girls were. I missed her. I missed her girls.
It’s now been three months or so since we last messaged and spoke about meeting up when she has time, chatting about various bits and bobs.
Also – what happened was she started ignoring my posts on social media – even when they were directly about her girls or things that directly related to her. This has been going on for months.
Now, very recently, more and more frequent posts from my ex’s new girlfriend have been turning up on my friend’s timeline and popping up on my newsfeed. Family BBQ’s round at my friend’s house. Days out. Weddings.
To be honest – I don’ t want to see these posts. It causes me pain. But the pain I feel is not down to seeing my ex with someone new. No. I am quite clear about that. It looks like my friend is now forming a close, intimate friendship with my ex’s new girlfriend. And again- the pain that I feel from this is not one of jealousy.
The pain I feel is that when I see these posts – it reminds me of the friendship that we once had. The sister that I once had. And the pain I feel now, I realise is part of the grieving process that I had not realised that I had to go through. The loss that I thought that I would never have to face. The loss of the one thing that was salvageable – or so I thought from the wreckage of 18 months ago.
Seeing those posts from my ex’s new girlfriend was a slap in the face- and it woke me up.
Our friendship is over.
So over in fact – that on my birthday last week – despite over one hundred of my friends and associates wishing me a happy birthday…….the one person that I thought would definitely post a “Happy Birthday” on my timeline – like she had done for so many years before – didn’t.
I teach about ‘endings’ to my counselling students. But the end that I am faced with now is not one that I have ever had to deal with before. I have a few close friends – some I have known from childhood. Some I have made in adulthood. All of which I am loyal to.
But I have never had to deal with the end of a friendship until now. How does it work?
I have tried to empathise with why this ending might be. That’s the thing about friendship. Friends have empathy for each other. Friends get when there is hurt, when there is anger, when you are facing something hard and painful and they do what they can to help and support and nurture and sometimes tell you things that are really hard to to take- but that need to be said. I got it that is was hard for her when I split from her brother – I didn’t turn to her for support for that very reason. I understood that her family had put me firmly in my designated role of ‘the bad one’. I knew this must have been conflicting for her. But I still always thought that she knew me better.
Maybe it was too hard for her – having a friendship with her brother’s ex? Maybe she didn’t like some of the things I posted on social media which referred to her brother? The truth is sometimes painful to swallow and as in most cases- there are two sides – two truths – to every story. Maybe my truth was one that she didn’t want to hear? Maybe she doesn’t actually know me as well as I thought she did? Maybe she was so taken in by the ‘victimisation’ of her brother that she really does believe that I am to blame for everything that happened. Maybe to admit that actually her brother also had responsibility for the failure of our relationship, would mean that she would have to try and reconcile this with the role of ‘victim’ that he had taken up? Maybe stepping off of the drama triangle was too much for her to do?
Whatever the reason, there was no communication from her about it. Ten years of friendship were just brushed under the carpet. No honest conversations. Nothing. No proper ending. Just ‘ghosting’.
So – as I lay in my hotel bed on Saturday night, I realised that I had been in denial, it seemed, for many months. I now needed to go through the hurt, the anger, to the acceptance in order to heal.
I thought about sending one last message, but realised it was pointless. Ghosting actions speak louder than words. I know it’s over. And what would I say?
I guess, if anything, it would be this:
“Thank you. Thank you for the fun, the laughter, the chance to share your life for the ten years that we were friends. I wish you the best of everything for the future for you and your girls and your husband and I am sorry that you have lost your friend. She was a very dear one. A very loyal one. A sister who tried to be there for you whenever you needed her, that defended you at times to your own family and I know how much this loss must have hurt you and I am sorry for us both that it’s over. And I get it. It’s okay. ”
But I didn’t send anything. I removed her from my friend’s list. I doubt she will even notice.
And I know that this is not a healthy ending. I know that I could have been the adult and tried to have a conversation with her about it. I could have advocated for our friendship, I know all of this. Just like she could have been the adult when my relationship with her brother was ending and advocated for me. But I guess it was too hard for her to do that. And I guess it’s too hard right now for me to say anything to her.
And as I said, I am trying to change my patterns of relating, to unravel my attachment style and that includes not holding on to things that really I need to let go of and to cherish and nurture what is present and real and lasting.
And true friendship lasts, no matter what……